Welcome to Tony's N.Y. Pizza, a delightful gem nestled in Marco Island, Florida, at 145 S Barfield Dr. This charming pizzeria stands out for its authentic New York-style pizza, capturing the essence of pizza culture born in the streets of NYC. With a commitment to quality and tradition, Tony's crafts each pie with care, ensuring that every bite transports you to the bustling pizzerias of New York City.

From the moment you walk through the doors, the inviting atmosphere envelops you. Whether you're dining in or opting for takeout, the friendly, service-oriented staff makes you feel right at home. The reviews from satisfied customers speak volumes; one thrilled patron, Fabiola Woods, proclaimed it to be "the best NY style pizza I've had in a long time outside of NYC." Such a ringing endorsement is hard to ignore!

The menu boasts a variety of tantalizing options, prominently featuring their pizzas. Priced reasonably, a classic cheese slice starts at just $4.99, while the pepperoni variation following closely at $5.49. You can enjoy a generous selection of toppings and generous cheese portions that have left many customers, like Andrew Gasworth, raving about the abundant toppings. You might find yourself tempted to explore beyond the pizza, with classic Italian subs such as the Eggplant Parmesan and the Chicken Parmesan, proving a perfect complement to your dining experience.

For those looking to indulge further, Tony's offers side dishes that are equally as satisfying. The meatballs served with marinara sauce and topped with shaved Romano cheese and basil are a must-try. You won’t want to miss the side sausage, which is carefully prepared and served with marinara sauce, making each bite delightful.

Among the standout recommendations includes the eggplant pizza that one customer described as "huge and loaded with eggplant and cheese." It's clear that Tony's N.Y. Pizza is not shy when it comes to generous portions, making it perfect for sharing—or keeping all to yourself! With such rave reviews from guests like Anne DeSimone, who enjoyed both the pizza and the Caesar salad with grilled chicken in what she described as a "packed" restaurant on a Thursday night, it’s evident that Tony's is a beloved local haunt.

In a nutshell, whether you're a pizza aficionado or simply seeking comfort food, Tony's N.Y. Pizza offers a culinary experience that is truly satisfying. With every bite, you'll appreciate the commitment to quality and authenticity that this establishment embodies. Next time you're craving pizza on Marco Island, make sure to stop by Tony's. You won't be disappointed!